Scope
Source
Edit
Review
Record
Scope the page
Identify the reader question, the type of content and the decisions it may influence. List the claims that need checking. A petition needs clear requests and a defined scope; a writing exercise needs clear instructions and an honest explanation of what it does.
Inspect the source record
Open important references, confirm their identity and locate the passage that supports the claim. Record publication dates, version information and any access limitations. Do not describe a paper as fully reviewed when only its abstract or a secondary summary was available.
Check the editorial choices
Read for structure, meaning, examples and unsupported certainty. Test whether a suggested edit preserves the actor, action, quantity, timing and conditions. Make the language proportionate to the evidence and the intended audience.
Use specialist review where needed
If a page depends on expertise beyond the editor’s competence, obtain a relevant specialist review before claiming that expertise. Record the person, their verified role, the scope of their review and the date. Specialist review is not implied by linking to a university or professional association.
Record the actual status
A review label should identify who checked which aspect and when. This launch edition has no verified named human or expert reviewer. Do not display “expert reviewed” or an equivalent assurance until the corresponding review has occurred.
Revisit material when it changes
A changed feature, source revision or credible correction report can justify a new check. Updating a date alone is not evidence of a new review. Keep an intelligible change record when the conclusion, scope or material facts change.