Ask what kind of response is useful

A draft may need help with its argument, its order or a final detail. Ask the writer which stage they are at and what question they want a reader to answer. If there is a brief or assignment, keep it nearby. Responding to a different task can create work without improving the piece.

Separate observation from interpretation

“The second section introduces a new audience” describes something you noticed. “I was unsure whether the instructions still applied to beginners” explains your response. Together, they give the writer a place to look and a reason to look there. A label such as “confusing” leaves too much of that work unstated.

Make a limited number of priorities

A page covered in equal-weight comments makes it difficult to choose what matters. Identify the changes that affect understanding first. A missing explanation may deserve attention before repeated punctuation slips. You can flag a pattern and show one instance without marking every occurrence.

Offer a reason alongside a suggestion

A proposed wording is easier to assess when the writer knows what it is meant to solve. “Move this definition earlier so a new reader can understand the comparison” gives a purpose. The writer may find a different solution that serves the same purpose better.

Leave the writer with agency

Ask a genuine question when the answer is uncertain. Do not rewrite a voice merely because it differs from your own. Make clear which comments concern an error, which concern the task and which reflect a preference. The writer remains responsible for the final choices and for checking the resulting meaning.

AN ORIGINAL WORKED EXAMPLE

Less useful

This paragraph is weak.

More useful

I understand the recommendation, but I cannot see the evidence for it. Could you add a source or explain the example before the conclusion?

ONE THING TO TRY

For each major comment, name a location, describe its effect on you and explain the purpose of a possible change.

Build a revision plan

Project credit: Human Readers. No named human or expert review is claimed for this launch guide.

Report a factual or editorial issue ↗
KEEP READING

Check the claim, not just the link.